Fashion trends have evolved to become more inclusive and fluid, blurring the lines between traditionally male and female attire. However, a subtle yet consistent distinction remains: the placement of buttons on garments. Typically, men’s shirts feature buttons on the right side, while women’s shirts have them on the left. This seemingly minor difference has deep historical roots, with various theories attempting to explain its origin.

​

Assistance in Dressing

One prevalent theory traces back to an era when affluent women employed maids to help them dress. Given that most individuals are right-handed, placing buttons on the left side of women’s garments made it more convenient for a maid facing the wearer to fasten them. Melanie M. Moore, founder of the women’s blouse brand Elizabeth & Clarke, explains, “When buttons were invented in the 13th century, they were, like most new technology, very expensive. Wealthy women back then did not dress themselves—their lady’s maid did. Since most people were right-handed, this made it easier for someone standing across from you to button your dress.”

Men’s Attire and Weaponry

In contrast, men typically dressed themselves, leading to buttons being placed on the right side for ease of use. Additionally, historical considerations related to weaponry influenced this design choice. Men often carried swords on their left side to be drawn with the right hand. Having garments that buttoned left over right prevented the sword from catching in the jacket opening during a draw. Paul Keers, author of “A Gentleman’s Wardrobe,” notes, “A gentleman’s sword was always worn on the left side, so that it could be drawn with the right hand. If a jacket buttoned right over left, the handle of the sword would be likely to catch in the jacket opening when drawn.” ​

Masculine Fashion Influences

By the 1880s, women’s fashion began incorporating more traditionally masculine elements. However, societal norms and legal restrictions often prohibited women from dressing like men in public. To maintain a clear distinction between genders, women’s clothing retained the left-side button placement. Fashion historian Chloe Chapin suggests, “In the 1880s, it was fashionable for women’s clothing to look more traditionally masculine. However, it was illegal in many places to be dressed like a man in public, so perhaps having a difference in buttoning confirmed that you were wearing a female dress.” ​

Symbol of Social Status

The direction of button placement also served as an indicator of social status. Buttons were initially expensive and signified wealth. For women, having buttons on the left side subtly indicated affluence, as it implied the presence of a maid to assist with dressing. This practice underscored societal structures where upper-class women were often dependent on their servants for daily tasks. ​

Gender Inequality Reflections

In 1894, British sexologist Havelock Ellis observed that the left-side button placement on women’s garments reflected perceptions of women as physically inferior to men. He argued that this design implied women lacked the motor skills to dress themselves, necessitating assistance, whereas men did not require such help. ​

Modern-Day Implications

Despite the original reasons for these button placements becoming obsolete, the tradition persists in contemporary fashion. Many clothing manufacturers continue to design garments with this gender-based distinction, even though the practical need has diminished. This enduring practice serves as a subtle reminder of historical gender roles and societal structures. ​

Public Awareness and Reactions

Awareness of this button placement difference has grown, leading to varied public reactions. Some individuals express surprise upon discovering the distinction, while others view it as an outdated tradition that reflects historical gender inequalities. Discussions on platforms like Reddit reveal that many people are just now learning about this detail, prompting reflections on its relevance in modern fashion. ​

Conclusion

The differing button placements on men’s and women’s shirts, though subtle, are steeped in history and tradition. Originating from practical considerations related to dressing assistance, weapon accessibility, and social status, this design element has persisted into modern fashion. While the original reasons may no longer apply, the continued use of gendered button placements serves as a reminder of past societal norms and the evolving nature of fashion